There’s been a lot of talk lately about boys who love to dress as princesses. Much discussion has centred on sexuality, whether boys should be allowed to wear “girls” clothes, the impact of gender stereotypes on individuality and being brave enough to support your children’s choices in their quest to be themselves. Who cares if a boy wears a dress as long as they’re happy? Why is so much attention paid to what boys and girls should, or should not, wear? Why can’t little boys feel comfortable in their own skin – even if it means wearing a tutu and carrying a wand?
Here’s the thing. In our house we have the opposite problem. We don’t own a princess outfit. We have a couple of hand me down ballet skirts and a few pairs of plastic high heels, but no real princess outfits. This could be considered strange, not because our boys want to wear them, but because we don’t have boys – we have three girls. Not one of them has expressed a desire to wear a princess outfit. In our house, Miss 4 would rather spend her days dressed as a cat.
Until we owned a proper cat costume she would just stuff a scarf down the back of her pants and call it a tail. The 2yo Who Never Sleeps has been inspired by her older sister and now she spends most of her days dressed as a dog. We’ve bought a bunny outfit for Baby 3 (just in case she too is into animals), but at the moment she wears whatever her big sisters’ put on her. At the moment she’s a kangaroo.
We are completely cool with Miss 4’s obsession with animals – it’s only when she gets on all fours in public places and licks the floor it gets a little embarrassing, not to mention unhygienic. But try explaining that to a cat. At least she hasn’t the flexibility to lick her own bottom. The only problem is many of the girls around her, and some of the boys, are really into princesses. We go to many princess parties and while she’ll dress up in a makeshift outfit I can tell she’d feel more comfortable in her cat costume. I should just let her wear it, and sometimes I do, but then I fear she’ll feel out of place. I just want to protect her.
I’ve even been giving Miss 4 a bit of a crash course in princesses and fairies so she knows what her friends are talking about. To prep her for conversations like this one I overheard the other day –
Girl 1: “I’m Rhapsody”
Girl 2: “I’m Harmony”
Miss 4: “I’m Madge”.
Madge is the name of her Grandma’s cat. The other two are characters from that awful show the Fairies.
I can understand the pressure on the parent’s of boys who like a good old fashioned princess outfit. That moment of guilt when you ask them to change before heading out or you suggest perhaps a Bob the Builder outfit might be more “suitable” for them. I am finding myself in the same predicament. But you know what, as those before me have said about their princess dressing boys, I just want my girls to be happy. I don’t want them to feel like they need to fit the mould of what “girls” are. If they want to spend their time wagging their tails and eating their food off a bowl on the ground – then so be it. As long as they’re confident and comfortable in their own skin – that’s all that matters. As long as they are brave enough to be who they want to be, even if it’s furry and has a tail. We are a world of difference, not everything’s blue or pink, sometimes it’s tabby.
Your girls are adorable and should be allowed to express themselves any which way! It is only our society and the norms we hand down from generation to generation that says that pink is for girls and blue for boys. I am certain that those colours feel rather offended by our behaviour and consider themselves rather gender-neutral! x
Lexie has a mouse obsession. White tights and a white long sleeve spencer and a pair of white mouse ears. And white thongs. Every day. She stinks.
My very non-princess daughter was also mad for cats. ALways wanted cat face paint rather than the butterflies that all the other little girls asked for. Thank goodness for Book Week when she could go as Puss in Boots amongst the princesses.
And I have a boy who is wasn’t particularly enamoured with superheroes. Nor princesses. He has gone as King Arthur, the Cat in the Hat (OMG cat again!) and Fantastic Mr Fox, among all the Spidermen (and Harry Potters).
Fuck, those kids are cute!!
Is it just instant gratification for them…’cos they want it now..and us…’cos we want peace…or is there a better choice for the long term good of the child. Is what is happening to Suri Cruz such a good thing long term…for her character..or her future?
She’s such a cute cat. I’m not sure I can comment appropriately though, with both boys and girls we have such an array of costumes, they seem to all mesh together. Our princess’ sometimes wear vampire teeth and Bob the Builder is often wearing a feather boa and Tiara. As you know, our 4 year old son chooses the dress option 99% of the time. Interestingly, 4 kids over 10 years….not ONE Princess party?? I wonder why? Kirsty
4 kids, 20 suitcases and a beagle
I agree wholeheartedly with what you have written! Well said. Amy is only just expressing an interest in “being a princess” and we have conversations about what she wants to be when she grows up and she will say “a princess” and I say how boring it would be to be a princess, why not an adventurer or an elephant trainer and that soon changes her mind. I am addressing it like any other phase that I am sure she will go through.
I think at this young age even the little princesses would all as a group be accepting of a little cat… as you say, what is important is that they are all comfortable in their own skins. They certainly know their own minds.
I still have fairies in my house…and princesses…and the occasional snow white – I live for those days when an occassional tiger or unicorn creeps into the games. My eldest, however, has a friend who still plays puppy dogs (at 9!!).
Oh and as for those fairies…I’m reeeeeally hoping not to have to do *that* whole thing again for a third time (fingers crossed)…but I’ve already given up and relented on the wiggles so I know it’s a slippery slope from there to fairies…but I’m holding on!!!
xxxCate
Love the pics!
My girls love to dress up as everything and anything, from Fairies to Buzz Lightyear. My son will have an array of costumes to choose from. Although he’ll have three sisters to contend with. He may just have to cop wearing a fairy outfit from time to time 😉
There are precious few years in life when we can dress as a cat and lick the floor in public. Princes-shmincess. Go Madge!
I think it is so very cool that your little girl likes to be a cat. Personally, I think it is far better than princesses.
my son is a sort of ‘manly boy’. he knows ‘pink is for girls’ (?) and princesses, he is the cowboy, knight, pirate. he looked VERY odd in a Supermario outfit though, that included red shorts, a too tight singlet and a painted on mustache…whoot! Like the lost son of the Village People! I am not sure I would have let him out like that lol, but I took many photos. blackmailing material for when he plays up at 16. Ah well, OR a dress idea for his first Mardi Gras in Sydney… I really wouldn’t care. Fortunately, our generation cares a bit more about HAPPY than about HOW they SHOULD look – or dress up!
Love this post and agree with you entirely. Kids need to go where their imaginations lead them. That’s the POINT of imaginary play! And Princesses are over-done. My girls are mostly into being horses. Though, one daughter did get a little confused a few weeks ago and wanted to be both at once. We called her Princess Palomino.
Viva la difference!
The first toy my daughter ever specifically requested was Buzz Lightyear when she was 2. Over the years she’s dressed as a princess on occasion….but she’s also dressed as a vampire, a pirate and numerous other characters, including animals.
She seems to have a foot in both camps. She’s not a stereotypical tomboy and she’s not a girlie girl (although those kids that *are* should be free to do that too. There’s nothing wrong with always wanting to be a fireman, policeman or superhero…..or always wanting to be a princess or fairy or ballerina).
And if some kids want to mix it up a bit (in terms of gender stereotypes)…..go for it, I say.
They are just playing and doing whatever feels good for them. So, as I said, Viva la difference!
Trish
xx
I don’t see why she can’t go to these parties as a cat. She could be a pet. Princesses do have pets. Mostly they are dragons though….
This is the speediest Disqus I’ve ever used. Most of the other blogs have a very slow Disqus and I gave up leaving comments there.
My daughter was obsessed with fairies and pirates and animals. She often went to dress up parties as as all three.
I love that your children have minds of their own. Anyone can be a princess! But I also understand that as parents we want our children to be accepted, and not feel left out.
I say though, is they are happy to be cats, let them!
BTW, your kids are gorgeous!
Gorgeous kids B 🙂
I have no idea what my little man would prefer…we have never played dress-ups! OMG what kind of terrible mother am I??? Must set about rectifying that, if for no other reason than to be able to take adorable pics like the ones in your post!
Your last line is absolutely adorable. For me – tabby would ALWAYS be the choice 🙂
That’s awesome. If I have a kid, I want him/her to dress like a cat 🙂
Pah. princesses and fairies stink, your gal so has the right attitude. All hail the cats!